Documents compared — Instinct: Terms and Privacy Policy, last revised August 26, 2026 · Muse: Supplemental Terms, updated September 8, 2026, and Privacy Policy, effective September 17, 2026 · Revision dates and the key clauses re-checked October 13, 2026 · We have not run the two agents side by side; every row traces to a dated document or a named report.
Instinct AI vs Muse AI
Short answer
Same job, opposite bets. Both are personal AI agents that act across your apps on your behalf. Instinct AI is a startup’s invite-only beta — free for everyone with access as of September 30, 2026, a $100 liability cap, and a training opt-out that only works going forward. Muse AI is Meta’s public launch — free with a usage limit plus $20 and $100 plans, a $250 cap that names the agent’s own unintended actions, and a training opt-out that also reaches past interactions. On the clauses people compare most, Muse’s documents commit to more; its first month gave the public record more to weigh.
This is a documents-first comparison. Every row below comes from the companies’ own terms, privacy policies, help pages, and store listings, or from a named, dated report — and each one says which. What it is not: a speed test. We don’t hold accounts on both agents, so this page doesn’t rank how well either one books a table or answers an email. It ranks what each company has put in writing, and what the public record shows so far.
The two at a glance
| Instinct AI | Muse AI | |
|---|---|---|
| Made by | Spear Street Technology, Inc., doing business as Instinct — a startup that raised a $1B Series C at a $10B valuation (per Reuters and Yahoo Finance, Sept 28, 2026) | Meta Platforms, Inc. — the party named in the Muse terms and on the store listings |
| In its own words | “The personal assistant thinks, plans, and acts to help you complete your everyday tasks.” (Privacy Policy) | “a secure, private personal AI agent that proactively helps with people’s goals and suggests ideas” (Meta announcement, Sept 8, 2026) |
| Under the hood | “It’s trained to use a phone and a computer. … It uses its devices in the same way that humans do.” (instinct.com) | Runs in “a dedicated, virtual machine (VM) that houses both the agent and a person’s data” (Meta announcement) |
| How you reach it | By text or call — “Text Instinct to get started” is the homepage’s call to action; the web app signs in at app.instinct.com | Apps for iPhone and Android, a Mac download, muse.ai on the web, and WhatsApp |
| Access | Invite-based beta — five invites per user; the waitlist asks for a phone number | Public US rollout, still “in limited testing” and not “available in all locations yet” |
| Price | Free for everyone with access as of Sept 30, 2026 (usecarly); no pricing page at our Oct 13 re-check | Free with a usage limit · Power $20/month · Maximum $100/month (Meta help center, re-checked Oct 13) |
| Training on your data | On by default; the opt-out at app.instinct.com/settings applies going forward only | On when you first use Muse; switching it off also applies to previous interactions |
| Advertising | The privacy policy says it doesn’t sell your information or disclose it to data brokers | Conversations and VM data are walled off from Meta’s ad systems, per the privacy policy |
| Liability cap | The greater of $100 or what you paid in the six months giving rise to the claim | The greater of $250 or what you paid in the prior twelve months — and it names the agent’s own unintended actions |
| Arbitration opt-out | Written notice to support@instinct.com within 30 days of agreeing | A mailed letter to Meta in Menlo Park within 30 days of agreeing |
| Store listings (Oct 13) | No app from its operator in a search of Apple’s US App Store | “Muse from Meta”: 4.9 stars from about 224,000 App Store ratings; 4.7 from about 78,000 Google Play reviews, 5M+ installs |
| First month on the record | TechCrunch’s Aug 24 report on testers’ privacy concerns; user-reported outages from the night of Sept 21 through Oct 2 | A 0-day patched in about 12 hours (Ars Technica, Sept 21); ZDNET’s “worst for privacy” verdict (Sept 28); disputed data-sync claims, with public rebuttals |
Every row is sourced at the bottom of the page, with dates. Where the exact wording carries the meaning, the sections below quote it in full.
Access: an invite wall vs a public rollout
Instinct’s gate is the invite itself. When we went through the sign-up flow on October 3, 2026, access ran through invites — five per user — and the official waitlist asked for a phone number before it would text you a spot. Texting is also the interface: there is no new app to learn, by design. Instinct’s terms do define “any related Mac OS application or other computer or mobile applications,” but a search of Apple’s US App Store on October 13, 2026 returned no app from its operator.
The invite path, and what could and couldn’t be verified about it, is in our Instinct AI setup guide.
Muse took the opposite route. The announcement, in one line:
“Muse is rolling out in the US on iOS, Android, and muse.ai, and coming soon to AI glasses.” Meta, “Introducing Muse” — September 8, 2026 (updated September 30)
Add WhatsApp, where the announcement says you can use Muse directly, and a Mac app that Meta’s download page serves as a direct download rather than through the Mac App Store. The gate is location, not a code: Meta’s subscription help page says Muse is “in limited testing” and isn’t available everywhere yet. The “invite codes” circulating for Muse are referral bonuses for extra usage, described in community posts — not a way in.
Everything we’ve written about getting Muse running is collected on the Muse AI hub.
Price: a free beta vs free with limits
“As of September 30, 2026, Instinct’s pricing page is an empty shell, the product is an invite-only beta, and every user is on the same free tier.” usecarly, “Instinct AI Pricing (2026)” — a dated third-party check
Our own re-check on October 13, 2026 found the same absence: instinct.com/pricing showed a “Page not found” screen in a browser. The terms already reserve the right to change that — “The Company may, at any time, revise or change the pricing for the Services, or any portion thereof” (§4).
The dated evidence, both views of the pricing URL, and the full §4 text are on our Instinct AI pricing check.
Muse publishes a price list:
| Muse plan | Meta’s own words |
|---|---|
| Free | “Muse is available for free with a usage limit.” |
| Power plan | $20/month — “500M Muse tokens per week” |
| Maximum plan | $100/month — “3B Muse tokens per week” |
Those are Meta’s own numbers from its subscription help page, checked October 9, 2026 and re-checked October 13. The Muse terms reserve the same kind of exit Instinct’s do, in stronger words: Meta can “modify or discontinue offering Muse for free … at any time and without prior notice.”
So both “free” labels are facts with dates, not promises. The structural difference is that Muse already has a paid ceiling you can buy past, and Instinct has no published plan at all.
Your data: two opposite training opt-outs
Instinct’s policy, on training and on what opting out does:
“If you do not want us to use your information to train AI models, you can opt out by visiting app.instinct.com/settings.” Instinct Privacy Policy — rev. August 26, 2026
“This opt out applies on a go-forward basis… We may still use AI models previously trained, fine-tuned or improved on your information prior to your opting out.” Instinct Privacy Policy — rev. August 26, 2026
Muse’s policy, on the same two questions:
“This setting is on when you first use Muse.” Muse Privacy Policy — effective September 17, 2026 (English re-checked via the Internet Archive snapshot of October 11, 2026)
“Changes to this setting also apply to previous interactions.” Muse Privacy Policy — effective September 17, 2026
That second Muse sentence is the biggest written difference between the two products. Both train on your activity by default; only Muse says that switching it off reaches backward. Neither can un-train a model that has already learned, and neither promises to.
The rest of the data picture splits the same way. Muse’s privacy policy says it “doesn’t share your conversations or the data in your virtual machine with Meta ad systems” — a promise only an ad company needs to make. Instinct’s strongest data protection is narrower: information from Google Workspace is excluded from model training and advertising, and other sources get no matching clause. And both documents warn that removing something isn’t the same as erasing it — Instinct: “we may still use the indexed Connected Service Input data unless you follow the instructions to request deletion”; Muse: “After you delete something, Muse may still ‘remember’ information it learned from what you deleted.”
When the agent gets it wrong: $100 vs $250
Instinct’s cap, in the terms’ own words:
“The Company Entities’ total liability to you for any damages finally awarded shall not exceed the greater of one hundred dollars ($100.00), or the amount you paid the Company Entities for the Services, if any, in the past six (6) months giving rise to the claim.” Instinct Terms of Service §9 — rev. August 26, 2026, re-checked October 13 (all-caps in the original)
Muse’s cap, and the sentence that follows it:
“Meta’s aggregate liability … will not exceed the greater of $250 or the amount you have paid us in the twelve months preceding the events giving rise to the most recent claim.” Muse Supplemental Terms of Service — updated September 8, 2026, re-checked October 13 via the Internet Archive snapshot of October 9 (all-caps in the original)
“This limitation applies to any claim arising from Muse taking any unintended, erroneous, or unauthorized action…” Muse Supplemental Terms of Service — updated September 8, 2026 (all-caps in the original)
On a free account the caps are $100 and $250. Muse’s is two and a half times higher and, unusually, names the agent’s own mistakes in writing. Instinct’s terms make the agent’s acts yours — agreements it makes are “binding on you as if entered into directly by you,” and Actions “may not always be reversible” — and leave the guard rails to you: “you remain responsible for configuring any additional safeguards or restrictions on Actions…”
Muse’s terms put a matching duty on you from the other direction. You are not to let it send communications, execute financial transactions, delete data, or change system configurations “without appropriate human review and approval prior to execution” — and you carry full responsibility for what it creates, which “applies whether or not you reviewed, inspected, or were aware of its contents before or after creation.” Meta’s help center adds the design side: “Many of these approval checks are enforced outside the AI model, so they don’t rely only on Muse deciding whether it should ask.”
Read together: neither cap comes close to what an agent with a card can spend in an afternoon. The safety settings matter more than the difference between $100 and $250.
Each product’s clause-by-clause check, with the settings that shrink the risk: is Instinct AI safe, and our Muse AI safety check.
The public record so far
Instinct AI
Aug 24, 2026 · TechCrunch (Sarah Perez). Four named early testers on the record: one kept receiving summaries after disconnecting, one had a deletion request refused, one saw an email sent without confirmation, and one ran a phishing test that worked. The report’s framing: the assistant is powerful, and it is raising privacy and security concerns.
Sept 21 – Oct 2, 2026 · TheStreet and r/AI_Agents. User-reported outages beginning the night of September 21 — TheStreet’s Sept 22 report carried the subhead “No status page, no statement” — with same-symptom reports on Reddit continuing through October 2, while some users reported recovery along the way. Instinct has no official status page.
Muse AI
Sept 21, 2026 · Ars Technica (Dan Goodin). Researcher Patrick Wardle showed a locally installed app could rewrite an undocumented Muse setting and capture the token controlling the whole account. Meta shipped a hotfix roughly twelve hours after publication and called it “not a remote exploit.”
Sept 28–29, 2026 · ZDNET, AppleInsider, CNET. ZDNET published “Meta Muse is the worst AI agent for privacy – and I’ve tried them all.” An AppleInsider forum post relayed a claim that Muse synced 187,000 lines of a user’s Messages despite Full Disk Access being off — and replies on the same thread pushed back, one with a canary test that was blocked as configured. CNET recounted a reviewer whose home address Muse shared with a Marketplace buyer under message permissions he says he didn’t realize he’d granted.
The two records fail differently. Instinct’s worst month was reliability — an agent that went quiet with no status page to say why. Muse’s was security and permissions — an agent with more reach than some users understood they had granted. On the other side of Muse’s ledger: the 0-day was patched within a day, and Meta has promised a Muse Confidential VM “later this year,” encrypted “with a key only they hold” — a future feature, not a current one.
Which one fits you
Our reading, not a verdict — matched to what you would actually connect:
You can’t get an invite.
Then the choice is made: Muse is publicly available in the US, and Instinct isn’t open without one.
Training on your history is the deal-breaker.
Muse’s opt-out is the stronger clause because it reaches past interactions. With Instinct, switch training off before you connect anything — the day you wait is a day it can’t take back.
You’d rather not hand an ad company your inbox.
Muse’s ad-system wall is in writing, but it is still Meta, and the terms reserve the right to “monitor, log, review, suspend, block, or modify Muse’s actions at any time.” Instinct’s written promise is narrower: no selling your information, no disclosure to data brokers.
You want an app on your phone or Mac.
Muse has one on each. Instinct is something you text.
You’d depend on it every day.
Neither month was clean. Instinct had an eleven-day stretch of user-reported outages with no status page; Muse had a patched 0-day and contested permission incidents. Whichever you choose, keep anything time-critical somewhere you control.
If neither fits, the other agent-style rivals and the general assistants are on our Instinct AI alternatives page.
What this page can and can’t tell you
We compare documents and the public record; we don’t benchmark. How fast either agent finishes a task, how often it gets one wrong, and how good its writing is are not on this page, because we haven’t measured them and won’t borrow someone else’s numbers without their date.
Both products are weeks old and moving. The documents here were re-checked on October 13, 2026; prices, plans, and terms can change — both companies reserve that in writing. If a row is wrong on the day you read it, its date will tell you which one went stale.
Frequently asked questions
Is Muse AI better than Instinct AI?
On paper, on the clauses most people compare, Muse commits to more: a $250 liability cap that names the agent’s own unintended actions (Instinct’s is $100), a training opt-out that also applies to past interactions (Instinct’s works going forward only), and a written wall between your data and Meta’s ad systems. It is also publicly available in the US, while Instinct needs an invite. Its first month had the rougher security record. We haven’t benchmarked how well either one does tasks.
Is Instinct AI or Muse AI safer?
It depends on which risk you weigh, and both get much safer with the right settings. Muse’s documents are stronger on liability, training and ads; Instinct’s first month was a reliability problem, Muse’s a security and permissions one (a 0-day patched in about twelve hours, per Ars Technica). Both safety pages on this site list the settings that shrink the risk, clause by clause.
Is Muse AI free like Instinct AI?
Partly. Instinct is free for everyone with access as of September 30, 2026, with no published paid plan. Muse is free with a usage limit, and sells Power at $20/month and Maximum at $100/month, per Meta’s help center (re-checked October 13, 2026). Both sets of terms let the company change pricing or end free access.
Do I need an invite code for Instinct AI or Muse AI?
For Instinct, yes — it is an invite-based beta with five invites per user and a waitlist. For Muse, no — it is rolling out publicly in the US; the codes that circulate for Muse are referral bonuses for extra usage, not access.
Who makes Instinct AI and Muse AI?
Instinct is operated by Spear Street Technology, Inc., doing business as Instinct, a startup that raised a $1B Series C at a $10B valuation per Reuters (September 28, 2026). Muse is made by Meta Platforms, Inc.
Which one trains AI models on my data?
Both, by default. Instinct’s opt-out is at app.instinct.com/settings and applies going forward only. Muse’s training setting is on when you first use it, and switching it off also applies to previous interactions, per its privacy policy effective September 17, 2026.
Is there an Instinct AI app for iPhone like Muse?
Instinct is designed to be texted — its homepage’s call to action is “Text Instinct to get started” — and a search of Apple’s US App Store on October 13, 2026 found no app from its operator. Muse has an iPhone and iPad app (“Muse from Meta,” requires iOS 18.0 or later), an Android app, and a Mac download.
Sources
- Instinct Terms of Service, last revised August 26, 2026 revision date and §9 liability text re-checked October 13, 2026 · agent, Actions, safeguards, §4 pricing, and §10 arbitration clauses
- Instinct Privacy Policy, last revised August 26, 2026 revision date re-checked October 13, 2026 · the training opt-out and its go-forward scope, the Google Workspace exception, the no-sale commitment, and the own-words definition
- instinct.com (homepage) and instinct.com/pricing homepage interface lines and call to action checked October 4, 2026 · pricing URL re-checked October 13, 2026 (browser: “Page not found”) · invites and waitlist from the sign-up flow, October 3, 2026
- “Instinct AI Pricing (2026)” — usecarly the September 30, 2026 free-tier check, quoted verbatim
- Reuters — Instinct’s Series C September 28, 2026 · $1B at a $10B valuation (also reported by Yahoo Finance the same day)
- “Instinct’s powerful AI assistant is raising privacy and security concerns” — Sarah Perez, TechCrunch August 24, 2026 · the four named testers
- “‘Hello are you frozen’: users say viral AI assistant Instinct is ghosting its users” — Mehab Qureshi, TheStreet via Yahoo Finance September 22, 2026 · “No status page, no statement”; the outage record continues in a dated r/AI_Agents thread through October 2
- Muse Supplemental Terms of Service, updated September 8, 2026 liability cap, unintended-action language, and arbitration opt-out re-checked October 13, 2026 via the Internet Archive snapshot of October 9 · approval duty, artifact responsibility, monitoring, and free-access clauses verified October 8
- Muse Privacy Policy, effective September 17, 2026 training default, retroactive opt-out, ad-system wall re-checked October 13, 2026 via the Internet Archive snapshot of October 11 · deletion semantics verified October 8
- “Introducing Muse: The World’s First Personal AI Agent Built for Everyone” — Meta published September 8, 2026, updated September 30 · definition, the VM, US availability, WhatsApp, and the Confidential VM roadmap
- “About Muse subscriptions” — Meta help center checked October 9, 2026, re-checked October 13 · Free, Power ($20/month), Maximum ($100/month), and the limited-testing sentence
- “How Muse handles your privacy, safety and security” — Meta help center the approval checks enforced outside the AI model
- Download Muse — AI at Meta checked October 13, 2026 · Mac served as a direct download; links to the official App Store and Google Play listings
- “Muse from Meta” — Apple App Store and Google Play listings checked October 13, 2026 · ratings, installs, and iOS 18.0 requirement as displayed that day
- “Muse, Meta’s extraordinarily privileged AI assistant, has a serious 0-day” — Dan Goodin, Ars Technica September 21, 2026 · the Wardle 0-day and the hotfix timeline
- “Meta Muse is the worst AI agent for privacy – and I’ve tried them all” — ZDNET September 28, 2026 · cited at headline level
- “Unsurprisingly, Meta’s new Muse AI agent blatantly ignores users permissions” — AppleInsider forums September 28, 2026 · the 187,000-lines claim and, equally cited, the rebuttals in the replies
- “Meta’s Muse Is Misbehaving in Mysterious Ways With Your Privacy” — Omar Gallaga, CNET September 29, 2026 · the shared-address incident
Every claim on this page traces to one of these, with its date. Where we checked something ourselves — the pricing URL, the App Store search, the store listings — the note says so. Anything that traces to none of them is our reading and is labelled as such.